
by: Clyde Middleton posted: 2009-11-04 15:42:00
Viewed 394 times. 2 Comments.
In just one slice of the pathetic claim of "640,000 is like a million jobs S&C'd!" we learn that there is nothing but air, and sometimes quite expensive air.
Check out these specifics, all from the data compiled and submitted by the Illinois State Board of Education:
In the official report, Wilmette Public Schools District 39 was credited with 166 jobs saved by stimulus aid. Superintendent Raymond Lechner said the number should be zero.At Dolton-Riverdale School District 148, stimulus funds were said to have saved the equivalent of 382 full-time teaching jobs -- 142 more than the district actually has.
A similar discrepancy was found in data for Kankakee School District 111, where the stimulus report logged the equivalent of 665 full-time jobs saved. "That's impossible," a top Kankakee school official said, adding that the entire payroll -- full and part time -- is 600 workers.
That's 166+382+665 = 1,213 jobs S&C'd claimed in the report. 166 should be zero. At least 142 too much at D-R. And at least (estimating - note the claim is FTEs) 165 too much at Kank.
So 1,213 is reduced by at least 473 to 740. That's a 39% MOE - presuming, of course, that if the stimulus money did not come then the school districts would have closed. Something closer to the truth is more likely a 90% MOE.
Can it really be that bad? Let's allow a district to explain itself:
Last spring, Dolton-Riverdale received $3.6 million in stimulus money and reported to the state that the money saved 181 teaching jobs. A follow-up report this fall on another installment of $750,000 brought the total to 201. The official state report states that stimulus money saved 382 jobs.But Carolyn Keith, the district's comptroller, said the data from the two reports overlap and should not be added together.
Ah, got it! So the 382 was simply two numbers added together that should not have been! Let's do quick check of the evidence:
1. The district employs 240 people
2. They got $3.6 million and saved 181 of them at a cost per job of roughly $19,900
3. Then they received $750,000 and saved, um, 20 I think ("brought the total to") at a cost of $37,500
So, without the stimulus money, the district would have fired 181 / 240 or 75% of its work force. Yeow!
Further, the 20 jobs it saved at a cost of $37,500 each is impressive. The total cost of an employee to a company is a multiple of salary (generally three times) when you consider fringe benefits and all the others costs of employing and housing a person in a company. But let's presume these are triage times and they can bring someone in for a simply doubling. That leaves $18,750 for salary, and $18,750 for overhead. At 2,080 hours a year, that's $9 an hour wage. A teacher. At $9 an hour. OK.
Notice, of course, that the $3.6 million saved enough jobs to employ those 181 folks at $4.78 an hour. A teacher.
Their explanation falls short.
But before we hang them, let's add some more rope:
The totals do not reflect any school jobs saved or created in Chicago, the state's biggest district and the recipient of at least $293 million in stimulus funds. Chicago schools budget chief Christina Herzog said the district easily saved at least 1,200 jobs because of the stimulus, but didn't report them as such because of directives from the state board. State officials dispute that.
An under-count? OK, so presume that the 1,200 jobs were added in. How much did those jobs cost? $293,000,000 / 1,200 = $244,167 each. Nice.
So did the money actually go to save or create jobs? Appears not:
It appears the state treasury -- not students or school districts -- was the prime beneficiary of the education stimulus jackpot in Illinois. In great measure, funds simply were used to replace general aid payments already owed to local districts by the state. That gave Gov. Pat Quinn breathing room in his struggle to rein in a whopping two-year budget deficit of more than $10 billion.
I bristle at the use of the word "jackpot" in this excerpt. My kids will be paying interest on the debt for Lil Blago's 2009 budget correction.
Let's see who actually compiled the data that reflected these wonderfully reliable jobs numbers:
Confusion reigns over why the numbers for many districts appear so off. Responsibility for collecting data and sending the figures to Washington fell to Quinn's office, which turned the task over to the state board.Board spokesman Matt Vanover said the data might be flawed and said the information was only as good as the numbers sent in by local districts. But officials of several districts contacted by the Tribune insisted they never provided the state with the jobs numbers used in the official tabulation.
Looks like a circular firing squad. I thought they only did those things in Iran and Yemen where the gene pool dries in the hot summer nights yet they copulate unsafely regardless. Yak and camel smell remarkably similar, did you know that? I guess I could have guessed it, but I hadn't really thought about it.
If these data reflect the quality behind "640,000 jobs saved or created" which magically becomes a million through Bidenesque extrapolation, we need a recount.
Tags: Stimulus,
Trackback url: http://patriotroom.com/article/tilt-the-obama-stimulus-jobs-report-errors-are-astounding/trackback
Oh my! Toys! They bought teaching toys! I've used those in college teaching. You're right - waste of money that have to be constantly calibrated, and do no more than allow a lazy teacher to touch the screen instead of using the computer's mouse.
Whew. Sorry about that!
In his letter, being sent out to Arpaio supporters today as part of a 100,000-person national direct mail drop, the sheriff calls Hayworth's decision to challenge McCain "courageous." And he pledges to help Hayworth "every step of the way." "Senator McCain has served this country admirably but it's time to replace his moderate or even liberal positions on taxes, the border, social causes and big bank bailouts with a consistent conservative like J.D.," Arpaio continues. "After years of running over Republican principles his entire career no election year conversion to our way of thinking will save his campaign from voters that want conservatives to be a part of the solution rather than part of the problem," he says.
Views: 4 Comments: 0
McCain now finds himself jammed, moving starkly — and often awkwardly — to the right, apparently in an effort to gain favor among the same voters whom Mr. Hayworth, a consistent voice for the far right, could pull toward him like taffy come summer. McCain now sharply criticizes the bailout bill he voted for, pivoted from his earlier position that the Guantánamo Bay detention facility should be closed, offered only a muted response to the Supreme Court’s decision undoing campaign finance laws and backed down from statements that gays in the military would be O.K. by him... “John is undergoing a campaign conversion,” Mr. Hayworth said. Hayworth’s radio-personality bluster and big emotions.. may now have a part in the greater populist narrative that threatens many of the nation’s more centrist Republicans.
Views: 18 Comments: 0
Iran said Tuesday that it had begun producing higher-grade enriched uranium, marking a new and potentially dangerous turn in Tehran's confrontation with the West over its nuclear ambitions... U.S. National Intelligence Director Dennis C. Blair told the House intelligence committee last week that "Iran has the scientific, the technical, the industrial capacity to produce enough highly enriched uranium for a weapon in the next few years and eventually to produce a nuclear weapon. The central issue is a political decision by Iran to do so."
Views: 24 Comments: 0
I wouldn't want my fingerprints on anything this administration or congress proposes. Reid told reporters the bill would be introduced on Tuesday, and that it would include an extension of the tax breaks... Reid did not say how expensive the jobs bill would be. The Senate had been considering a package of roughly $80 billion. The House passed a larger jobs bill before Christmas, but now plans to unveil a different bill independent of that package, which did not garner Republican support.
Views: 53 Comments: 0
Back in November, the House passed its health care bill by a narrow 220 to 215 margin, with 39 Democrats voting against it. Since then, the one Republican who voted for it — Joseph Cao — has indicated that he would not support the bill a second time around given the weaker language on abortion in the Senate version. In addition, Florida Rep. Robert Wexler already retired prematurely. Factor in Murtha’s death today, and Pelosi is down to 217 votes — one short of passage. To pass the bill at some point in the next few months, she’ll need to flip a Democrat who is already on record voting against the bill.
Views: 121 Comments: 1
Don't think that Republicans can't be sucked in when an anti-Wall Street lynch mob gets its blood up. Recall that Sarbanes-Oxley, the devastating antigrowth response in 2002 to the Enron and Worldcom scandals, was passed with virtually unanimous support by Republicans in Congress, and signed by a Republican president. Recall that last year 85 House Republicans voted for a 90% tax on bonuses for any employee of any bank that took more than $5 billion in TARP money. Investors got some good news last Friday. Stocks resisted following through on Thursday's sharp plunge after (Congress) reached an impasse on bank re-regulation. That's a nice down payment on what investors need a lot more of now: proof that the GOP won't join Democrats in a populist rush to seek revenge against Wall Street.
Views: 78 Comments: 3
Just two years after Mr. Obama helped his party pull in record Wall Street contributions — $89 million from the securities and investment business, according to the nonpartisan Center for Responsive Politics — some of his biggest supporters, like Mr. Dimon, have become the industry’s chief lobbyists against his regulatory agenda. Republicans are rushing to capitalize on what they call Wall Street’s “buyer’s remorse” with the Democrats. And industry executives and lobbyists are warning Democrats that if Mr. Obama keeps attacking Wall Street “fat cats,” they may fight back by withholding their cash.
Views: 78 Comments: 2
The Dow, down almost 104 points, had its 10th triple-digit move in 16 trading days. Shares of big banks pulled the market lower, extending a slump that has led to four straight weekly losses.I can't, for the life of me, understand why bank stocks would be dropping. Inexplicable.
Views: 57 Comments: 2
Contrary to President Obama's promises, voters say special interests have more influence on the political process now than they did a year ago, according to a new poll. The poll, paid for by groups looking to curb the Supreme Court's recent campaign finance ruling, found that majorities of both Republicans and Democrats say special interests have increased their influence since the president took office, and they say Mr. Obama has not done enough to fight back.
Views: 59 Comments: 1
If the starting point for this meeting is the job-killing bills the American people have already soundly rejected, Republicans would rightly be reluctant to participate,” the pair explained in a letter to White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel. They also said President Barack Obama should remove reconciliation from the table. Using budget reconciliation rules to move healthcare reform in the Senate would mean Democrats would only need 51 votes on procedural measures instead of 60... On Sunday afternoon however, Obama refused to say he would start from scratch.
Views: 65 Comments: 2
As a Wilmette District 39 parent, I can tell you where the money went. Nearly every classroom got a "smartboard", some tech idiots idea of how to tech kids. It's an interactive whiteboard - think touch screen tv. It was a total waste of money, a complete gimmick that most teachers are not even using. At around $5,000 per unit we would have been better off gold plating the toilets. Chalk and eraser of the blackboard costs around 8 bucks. Installers might have made some bucks, but no jobs were created. I was angry when I learned about them and furious to find out we took stimulus money. This is one of the more affluent communities in the state, we did not need the fund. We particularly did not need "smartboards".
http://www.wilmette39.org/d39foundation/SmartBoards-article.pdf