On Politics, We Can Always See the Whites of Their Eyes.
Uh Oh: Even Liberals Think Sotomayor Too Dumb for Supreme Court
by: Bill Dupray posted: 2009-05-26 13:26:00
Viewed 1140 times. 16 Comments.
Forget ideology for a minute. It doesn't matter on which side of the political aisle you stand. Everyone should seek and hope for the brightest minds possible for the Supreme Court. Earlier this month, Jeffrey Rosen at the liberal New Republic, was profiling potential SCOTUS nominees and did a little write up on Judge Sotomayor that was well, less than charitable. In fact it probably falls more into the category of hit-piece and a warning to the administration to avoid this judge.
This is a lefty writer, at a lefty rag, interviewing lots of lefties who know Sotomayor, and who really want a lefty Justice on the High Court. And they think she is too dumb.
But despite the praise from some of her former clerks, and warm words from some of her Second Circuit colleagues, there are also many reservations about Sotomayor. Over the past few weeks, I've been talking to a range of people who have worked with her, nearly all of them former law clerks for other judges on the Second Circuit or former federal prosecutors in New York. Most are Democrats and all of them want President Obama to appoint a judicial star of the highest intellectual caliber who has the potential to change the direction of the court. Nearly all of them acknowledged that Sotomayor is a presumptive front-runner, but nearly none of them raved about her. They expressed questions about her temperament, her judicial craftsmanship, and most of all, her ability to provide an intellectual counterweight to the conservative justices, as well as a clear liberal alternative.The most consistent concern was that Sotomayor, although an able lawyer, was "not that smart and kind of a bully on the bench," as one former Second Circuit clerk for another judge put it. "She has an inflated opinion of herself, and is domineering during oral arguments, but her questions aren't penetrating and don't get to the heart of the issue." (During one argument, an elderly judicial colleague is said to have leaned over and said, "Will you please stop talking and let them talk?"). . . .
Her opinions, although competent, are viewed by former prosecutors as not especially clean or tight, and sometimes miss the forest for the trees. . . .
Some former clerks and prosecutors expressed concerns about her command of technical legal details: In 2001, for example, a conservative colleague, Ralph Winter, included an unusual footnote in a case suggesting that an earlier opinion by Sotomayor might have inadvertently misstated the law in a way that misled litigants.
And the knockout punch. Keep in mind no partisan Republicans took part in this thrashing.
It's possible that the former clerks and former prosecutors I talked to have an incomplete picture of her abilities. But they're not motivated by sour grapes or by ideological disagreement--they'd like the most intellectually powerful and politically effective liberal justice possible. And they think that Sotomayor, although personally and professionally impressive, may not meet that demanding standard. Given the stakes, the president should obviously satisfy himself that he has a complete picture before taking a gamble.
And the dumbing-down of the Supreme Court (thank you Affirmative Action) begins. Everybody said David Souter was odd, quirky, and boring. But nobody ever said he was an idiot.
Related Articles
- Contest: Win a pre-release copy of John Yoo's 'Crisis and Command' in time for Christmas delivery!
- Dems Said The Class Act “Ponzi Scheme” Strip It, But It Is Included In Final Health Care Bill
- Novel idea: It is Time for Republican Leaders to Step Down - on Principle
- Excellent one-click tweet and contact page for important Senators - Please RT
Links to this post
Trackback url: http://patriotroom.com/article/uh-oh-even-liberals-think-sotomayor-too-dumb-for-supreme-court/trackback
Comments 16
And liberal haters at that. Just amazing. I'm ... I'm shocked! Shocked, I tell you!
I am with Jim Smith and Clyde. Who knew that liberals were so elitist and condescending? I am sure she got into those great schools solely on the merits of her intellectual firepower.
I may be wrong, but I don't think Yale Law gives honor categories. I know it doesn't give grades, so I would suspect that designating any of its graduates with honors would be very difficult.
Not to mention unfair to all the non-winners (we avoid using the term "losers." It affects self-esteem).
I love people who think degrees and awards granted by leftist institutions and leftist professors have any relation to intelligence. Silly, silly people.
You're so right, Scott.
I didn't even graduate high school. Would you have known that by my comments here if I hadn't told you?
Of course, some people think I'm as dumb as a rock. Usually it's those who have degrees from "leftist institutions." Those are insane asylums, aren't they? :-)
Book learning pales compared to life experience. Never let a piece of paper on the wall define someone's worth or intelligence in comparison to yourself.
Don't be so quick on Souter. I don't think history will ever look on him as an intellectual heavyweight.
I think Sotomayor is the natural choice for Souter's legacy. Just as Bush 41 needed to nominate a black man for Thurgood Marshall's seat, and Bush 43 wanted a woman for O'Connor's seat, I think that Sotomayor is filling the idiot seat.
Now if we could only take that seat and place it in the corner of the courtroom, it would be more appropriate.
Is she a woman? Man, she sure is UGLY!
It's a well-known fact that conservative women are much hotter than liberal women.
Yeah, like that MAN in woman's clothing, Ann Coulter.
First, why do people nowadays get labeled a 'hater' if they have an opinion that differs? Is it the new label that gets thrown around in place of (or along side of) 'racist' ? Labeling someone a 'hater' is not a coherent argument for or against something!
Second, Are you blind Jason? Ann Coulter is smokin' HOT!!
"Ann Coulter is smokin' HOT!!"
Because she is the devil....:)
Have an opinion?
blog advertising is good for you
blog advertising is good for you
Publius' Newsstand
-
Congressional Democrats point finger of blame a...
Poor guy. One of the problems with yelling at people, berating people, and generally thuggish behavior towards people is that it doesn't exactly engender loyalty. Eventually they turn, even if it's not your fault.The share of the blame comes as cracks are beginning to show in Emanuel’s once-impregnable political armor... on Capitol Hill he’s under fire for poor execution of the president’s healthcare agenda in the Senate... Senate Democrats grilled White House advisers last week during a special Senate Democratic retreat, expressing frustration over the lack of a clear plan. While Sen. Al Franken (D-Minn.) ripped chief political strategist David Axelrod, Senate Democrats say Emanuel, who was more closely involved in managing negotiations in Congress, also deserves scrutiny.
Views: 1 Comments: 0
-
Michelle O: Barry has done a "phenomenol job"
A solid B-plus:Michelle Obama defended her husband against some of his most vocal critics, saying President Obama did a "phenomenal" job this year and that change is a long-term process. The first lady talks about her nationwide campaign called "Let's Move." "I think my husband has done a phenomenal job staying on course, looking his critics in the eye, coming up with clear solutions against staying the course," Michelle Obama told Robin Roberts in an exclusive morning television interview on "Good Morning America." "That's what leadership is. But people have the right to criticize the President of the United States."
Let me finish that last thought for you, Michelle. I see you rubbing your hands together and thinking, "Yes, for now people have the right to criticize him, but we're working on changing that."Views: 32 Comments: 0
-
Sheriff Joe Arpaio Lends Fundraising Muscle to ...
Following on the last story, this certainly will help.In his letter, being sent out to Arpaio supporters today as part of a 100,000-person national direct mail drop, the sheriff calls Hayworth's decision to challenge McCain "courageous." And he pledges to help Hayworth "every step of the way." "Senator McCain has served this country admirably but it's time to replace his moderate or even liberal positions on taxes, the border, social causes and big bank bailouts with a consistent conservative like J.D.," Arpaio continues. "After years of running over Republican principles his entire career no election year conversion to our way of thinking will save his campaign from voters that want conservatives to be a part of the solution rather than part of the problem," he says.
Views: 46 Comments: 0
-
From Right of Radio Dial, a Challenge to McCain...
Not buying it, Senator McCain.McCain now finds himself jammed, moving starkly — and often awkwardly — to the right, apparently in an effort to gain favor among the same voters whom Mr. Hayworth, a consistent voice for the far right, could pull toward him like taffy come summer. McCain now sharply criticizes the bailout bill he voted for, pivoted from his earlier position that the Guantánamo Bay detention facility should be closed, offered only a muted response to the Supreme Court’s decision undoing campaign finance laws and backed down from statements that gays in the military would be O.K. by him... “John is undergoing a campaign conversion,” Mr. Hayworth said. Hayworth’s radio-personality bluster and big emotions.. may now have a part in the greater populist narrative that threatens many of the nation’s more centrist Republicans.
Views: 31 Comments: 0
-
Defiant Iran accelerates nuclear program
I thought Obama was going to talk these things over with his boy Mahmoud and smooth everything out. Instead, Ahmadinejad remains "defiant." How's that hope-y change-y working out for us?Iran said Tuesday that it had begun producing higher-grade enriched uranium, marking a new and potentially dangerous turn in Tehran's confrontation with the West over its nuclear ambitions... U.S. National Intelligence Director Dennis C. Blair told the House intelligence committee last week that "Iran has the scientific, the technical, the industrial capacity to produce enough highly enriched uranium for a weapon in the next few years and eventually to produce a nuclear weapon. The central issue is a political decision by Iran to do so."
Views: 31 Comments: 0
-
Reid's Jobs Bill will have "Republican Support"
Looks like there's been some compromise here, as the GOP gets an extension of tax cuts that expired last year. I don't know if this is a good thing - I don't see much incentive for the GOP to do anything but obstruct the Dems at every possible point between now and November.I wouldn't want my fingerprints on anything this administration or congress proposes. Reid told reporters the bill would be introduced on Tuesday, and that it would include an extension of the tax breaks... Reid did not say how expensive the jobs bill would be. The Senate had been considering a package of roughly $80 billion. The House passed a larger jobs bill before Christmas, but now plans to unveil a different bill independent of that package, which did not garner Republican support.
Views: 58 Comments: 0
-
Without Murtha, Dems now one vote short of pass...
Didn't realize the implications of Murtha's passing today, which include the following...Back in November, the House passed its health care bill by a narrow 220 to 215 margin, with 39 Democrats voting against it. Since then, the one Republican who voted for it — Joseph Cao — has indicated that he would not support the bill a second time around given the weaker language on abortion in the Senate version. In addition, Florida Rep. Robert Wexler already retired prematurely. Factor in Murtha’s death today, and Pelosi is down to 217 votes — one short of passage. To pass the bill at some point in the next few months, she’ll need to flip a Democrat who is already on record voting against the bill.
Views: 124 Comments: 1
-
Republicans and the Populist Temptation could T...
A warning from my favorite economic analyst, Donald Luskin.Don't think that Republicans can't be sucked in when an anti-Wall Street lynch mob gets its blood up. Recall that Sarbanes-Oxley, the devastating antigrowth response in 2002 to the Enron and Worldcom scandals, was passed with virtually unanimous support by Republicans in Congress, and signed by a Republican president. Recall that last year 85 House Republicans voted for a 90% tax on bonuses for any employee of any bank that took more than $5 billion in TARP money. Investors got some good news last Friday. Stocks resisted following through on Thursday's sharp plunge after (Congress) reached an impasse on bank re-regulation. That's a nice down payment on what investors need a lot more of now: proof that the GOP won't join Democrats in a populist rush to seek revenge against Wall Street.
Views: 78 Comments: 3
-
Message to Democrats: Wall St. Sends Cash to GO...
Great news, but these guys were a little late in realizing that Obama wants to destroy all their corporations and confiscate their money. Not quite sure how they missed that.Just two years after Mr. Obama helped his party pull in record Wall Street contributions — $89 million from the securities and investment business, according to the nonpartisan Center for Responsive Politics — some of his biggest supporters, like Mr. Dimon, have become the industry’s chief lobbyists against his regulatory agenda. Republicans are rushing to capitalize on what they call Wall Street’s “buyer’s remorse” with the Democrats. And industry executives and lobbyists are warning Democrats that if Mr. Obama keeps attacking Wall Street “fat cats,” they may fight back by withholding their cash.
Views: 78 Comments: 2
-
Dow closes below 10,000 for first time in 3 mon...
The Dow sinks below a major psychological threshold.The Dow, down almost 104 points, had its 10th triple-digit move in 16 trading days. Shares of big banks pulled the market lower, extending a slump that has led to four straight weekly losses.
I can't, for the life of me, understand why bank stocks would be dropping. Inexplicable.Views: 57 Comments: 2
Get Your PR Button!
More Articles By Bill Dupray
- I thought of killing myself, says climate scandal professor Phil Jones
on 2010-02-07 with 148 views - Poll: Believers in man-made global warming rapidly dwindling
on 2010-02-07 with 610 views - Obama's never-before-seen 2010 strategy
on 2010-02-07 with 597 views - Classic liberal headline: New Orleans elects first white mayor since 1978
on 2010-02-07 with 140 views - In Full: Palin's Tea Party Speech
on 2010-02-07 with 237 views - Video: Dems cheer after raising Americans' debt limit to $14,294,000,000,000
on 2010-02-04 with 383 views - Mark Kirk puts Blago front and center in new campaign ad
on 2010-02-04 with 130 views - Scott Brown's 41st vote already giving Reid fits
on 2010-02-04 with 279 views - Obama jokes about his citizenship at Prayer Breakfast
on 2010-02-04 with 207 views - House faces tough vote on $1.9 trillion more debt
on 2010-02-04 with 81 views
Too dumb, eh? She graduated summa cum laude from Yale, high honors from Princeton, and was the editor of the Yale law review.
Sounds like haters to me.